How Small Law Firms Can Beat the Huge Advertisers

By Matt Starosciak
You will never outspend Morgan & Morgan. The good news is you don’t have to.
The mega advertisers are pushing into every market. In personal injury it’s most obvious, but criminal defense and divorce firms are putting the pedal down too. And it isn’t only the national brands. Statewide firms are spending enormous sums on TV and billboards.
I see a lot of firms respond by trying to play the big-budget game without the big budget. It’s a failed strategy. On a recent episode of The Law Firm CMO Playbook Podcast, Carl Downey and I walked through what works instead. Here’s the playbook.
Step 1: Stop playing their game
The first change is a mindset change. Instead of asking how to match the big spenders, ask what you can do that’s different. What advantages do you have in your own county that a national advertiser doesn’t?
Then make it real with money. Carve out a portion of your marketing budget for local, unique campaigns. Next, assign someone to find those opportunities. Most firms don’t have a person in-house with the time or skill to do it, so this is often where a marketing consultant or fractional CMO comes in.
Finding opportunities means picking up the phone. Call the local newspaper, the billboard company and the parks and recreation department. One placement I’ve been putting clients on lately: the EV chargers in front of grocery stores like Kroger and Publix. They look great, especially at night, and you can’t walk past them without seeing the ad.
Step 2: Stack placements so people see you again and again
A single shopping-cart sign won’t move the needle. Neither will one billboard, one banner or one newspaper ad. One is never enough. The power comes from stacking placements so the same people see you in several places.
Picture a family’s Saturday. They pass your billboard on the way to the ball field. At the field, your banner hangs on the back of the dugout. After the game, they go to the sports bar with the team and see your sign by the bathroom sink. That’s three impressions in one afternoon.
Years ago, a criminal defense client in Georgia told me his goal: become the household name in his county. Here’s some of what we stacked for him:
- A couple of billboards on major roads, instead of five or six
- Video monitors at the DMV, where people wait to renew licenses and plates
- EV charger ads in grocery store parking lots
- Banners in nine county parks, placed by dugouts and concession stands, not tossed on an outfield fence. Often the only other banner in the park was the sheriff’s office recruiting ad.
- Outlet mall directory signs during the holiday season
- Signage in restaurants, bars and gyms, by the drinking fountain or in the restrooms
- A weekly sponsorship of high school football scores in the local paper, covering all six county schools, with a large “scores sponsored by” banner
- Community magazine ads, such as a half-page every other month or in special editions
There are exceptions to the “never just one” rule. A DUI client once secured a banner on a building right outside the impound yard. Everyone leaving the lot saw it. A placement that perfect can stand alone, but those are rare.
Step 3: Rotate your spend so you feel like you’re everywhere
You don’t need to be everywhere at once. You need people to believe you are.
With few exceptions, I rotate the dollars. I rarely keep a client on the same billboard longer than four to six months. We don’t abandon the campaign; we move that money to another board. We might run the newspaper for a year, or just the football scores, and then shift that budget somewhere new.
Over time, people start saying, “I see you everywhere.” They aren’t seeing you everywhere at the same time. They saw your boards for six months, then your ads somewhere else for six months. The impression is total coverage, but the budget never has to pay for total coverage.
This is also why so many community magazine campaigns get cut after six months or a year. The firm ran one ad as its only local tactic. Nobody heard anyone mention it, so it looked like a waste. Real hyper-local branding creates buzz. People may not remember the magazine, but they remember seeing you somewhere.
What it costs (less than you think) and what it takes (more than you think)
The placements themselves are often cheap. A few real numbers from the client above:
| Placement | Cost |
| Weekly high school football scores sponsorship in the local paper | About $600 a week for 15 weeks |
| Nine banners in county parks, plus a full wrap on the community bus that takes seniors to appointments and shopping | About $950 a month, total |
Because each piece is inexpensive, you need a lot of them. You can’t bite off one piece and expect results.
The real cost is work. Someone has to find the opportunities, negotiate the contracts and produce creative that looks great. Someone also has to maintain it. Banners on a ball field fence will get damaged and pulled down, so someone has to go out with zip ties. If you aren’t up for that, this isn’t your strategy.
That effort is exactly why it works. I’ve built these programs for a select few firms, and nobody has copied them. I don’t think it’s budget. It’s just hard to do. You don’t see Morgan & Morgan in the county park dugout. Not yet, anyway. The big advertisers have the money to send people out to do all of this, and some are buying local firms. The window may not stay open forever.
Go beyond ad placements: community programs
Some of the best exposure I’ve ever earned for a firm cost almost nothing in hard dollars.
End Distracted Driving (EndDD.org) provides a ready-made presentation that law firms can give to local high schools. The stats and research are supplied; your attorney adds a personal touch. At a high school in North Atlanta, one of our attorneys gave the presentation to the whole student body.
Then we went further. I got the fire department to put a totaled car on the front lawn and demonstrate an extraction with the Jaws of Life. Imagine the entire school watching them cut that car open. The local news came out to cover it. We captured video and photos of everything.
The cost? The attorney’s time, some legwork on my end and a call to the school, which was glad to say yes. The return was huge, and the content kept working in our marketing long after. I’ve rarely seen another firm do it.
Public-service content works too. Recently a bill in the state house threatened to hurt veterans, a core client group for one firm. We filmed leaders from the state VFW explaining its potential impact, then promoted the video. It put the firm at the center of an issue its future clients cared about.
Get involved: referrals, reputation and recognition
As Carl pointed out, the firms that win locally are involved locally. That means the local bar association, the chamber of commerce and speaking at conferences and CLEs. It positions you as the go-to lawyer in your region and drives referrals the big advertisers can’t reach.
It pays off in less obvious ways too. Community involvement often weighs into ratings and awards like AV Preeminent and Super Lawyers, and those honors build on each other. One of my clients recently received a lifetime achievement award from ALM. Much of his nomination focused on his community work, including photos of him outside the Habitat for Humanity homes his firm sponsored and built every holiday season.
Marketers know these connections. Most practitioners don’t think about them. The catch is that this takes lawyer time, and there’s only so much of it to go around.
Sports marketing: the high-visibility bargain
Local sports may be the best value in hyper-local marketing.
Carl shared a recent win. His client, a PI firm competing with Morgan & Morgan and Top Dog Law, practices in rural counties with no major university. But there’s a busy community college nearby. Carl asked the school how the firm could get involved. The result was banners across the baseball, softball, soccer and lacrosse fields, which see thousands of visitors every summer.
Then the community made it their own. The firm’s banners hang in left and right field, so a ball hit into that gap now gets its own nickname, named after the attorney. You can’t buy that kind of word of mouth.
Carl didn’t stop at the signs. He took photos, interviewed the athletic director, wrote a press release, added the story to the firm’s website and pitched it to local news. The total cost was a fraction of what he expected. Other colleges quoted far more, which is worth knowing: shop around.
One of my favorites: a couple of local high school baseball teams in one client’s market won state championships. With permission, we put up the team photo with the trophy, reading “Congratulations to the Woodstock State Champions,” with the firm’s name in small print. Only the coach and booster club knew it was coming. When it went up, families shared it all over social media and the team posed beside it. It cost a few thousand dollars, and I’d take it over a generic “we’re a good law firm” billboard any day.
One sponsorship can be marketed many ways: a first pitch, a PA announcement, a press release. And the money supports local kids and teams.
Plan it, or don’t do it
A good idea still needs a good plan. Don’t run one event halfway, then decide “this strategy didn’t work.” Build a game plan for the next 6 to 12 months.
- Budget up front. Decide at the start of the year what you’ll spend on community involvement.
- Assign owners. Name a point person for each event.
- Keep a calendar. Know what’s coming so you’re always ready for the next thing.
- Stock your swag. If people expect your branded ice packs at the summer barbecue every year, have them ready.
- Document everything. Bring a photographer, professional or not. The photos and video fuel your marketing long after the event.
The payoff
That Georgia criminal defense lawyer set out years ago to become the household name in his county. Today he can’t go anywhere without being recognized. He invested real money to get there, and it’s been well worth it.
There’s a longer-term payoff, too. When he’s ready to step away, all that goodwill and name recognition is an asset that adds value to his firm. Don’t underestimate that.
You don’t need a mega budget to beat the mega advertisers in your backyard. You need the right strategy and the right people executing it.
Want help building a hyper-local plan for your firm? Contact Proven Law Marketing to talk about fractional CMO and local marketing services. For more strategies like these, listen to The Law Firm CMO Playbook Podcast on Apple Podcasts or YouTube.
